Jewellery isn’t just something you wear — it’s something you treasure. Whether it’s a gift from a loved one, a family heirloom, or a piece you bought to celebrate a special moment, the emotional value is often far greater than the price tag.
So, when that special piece gets damaged, it’s natural to wonder: Should I repair it, or is it time to replace it?
The right choice depends on several factors, and sometimes, what looks like a major problem can actually be an easy fix.
When Repairing Is the Right Choice
1. Sentimental Value Matters
Some pieces simply can’t be replaced. If the jewellery holds deep personal meaning — perhaps it’s your grandmother’s engagement ring or a bracelet gifted by a close friend — repairing it is usually worth it. Even extensive damage can often be restored by a skilled jeweller.
2. The Damage Is Relatively Minor
Common problems like loose stones, snapped chains, worn settings, or broken clasps are usually straightforward to repair. These fixes are typically inexpensive compared to replacement and can breathe new life into the piece without losing any of its history.
3. Expert Restoration Can Make It Like New
Sometimes a piece looks too worn to save — but you’d be surprised what professional restoration can achieve. From resetting stones to polishing out years of wear, a talented jeweller can often return your jewellery to its original beauty, or even improve its structure and longevity.
Before you make a decision, get an expert opinion — a repair may be easier (and more affordable) than you think.
When It Might Be Time to Replace
1. Severe Structural Damage
If a ring is cracked in more than one place, a chain is beyond repair, or settings have worn down too much to hold gemstones safely, it might not be wise to keep repairing it. Constant fixes can become costly and still not guarantee the piece’s strength.
2. The Cost of Repair Is Too High
In some cases, the materials and craftsmanship needed to repair a piece outweigh the cost of creating a new one. When this happens, a jeweller should walk you through your options clearly and honestly, balancing the financial and sentimental factors.
3. You’re Ready for Something New
Perhaps the damage is just the nudge you needed to redesign an old piece. Many jewellers offer services to repurpose stones and precious metals from damaged jewellery into completely new designs — keeping the sentimental value while giving you a fresh, modern piece to wear proudly.
Examples of Jewellery Repairs That Can Be Done
Rings:
- Resizing (too tight or too loose)
- Re-tipping or rebuilding worn prongs
- Replacing missing or damaged stones
- Polishing out scratches or dullness
- Re-shanking (replacing the back of the band if worn thin or broken)
Chains & Necklaces:
- Repairing snapped or stretched chains
- Replacing broken clasps or fasteners
- Soldering links back together
- Untangling and reconditioning knotted or kinked chains
Bracelets:
- Fixing broken links or charms
- Replacing lost safety chains or clasps
- Adjusting sizing of links
- Reattaching broken decorative elements
Earrings:
- Replacing lost earring backs
- Repairing broken posts or hooks
- Resetting or replacing missing stones
- Converting clip-ons to pierced or vice versa
Watches:
- Replacing batteries
- Repairing or replacing watch straps or bracelets
- Glass/screen replacement (if scratched or cracked)
General Repairs & Restorations:
- Cleaning and polishing to restore shine
- Rhodium plating to revive white gold
- Re-engraving faded personal messages
- Re-stringing pearls or beaded jewellery
- Reinforcing antique or delicate items
Why Getting Professional Advice Matters
When facing damaged jewellery, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. You might assume a broken clasp or a missing stone means the end of the piece — but very often, that’s not the case.
A reputable jeweller will always assess the damage thoroughly, talk you through your options, and recommend the most cost-effective, lasting solution. Sometimes, all it takes is a simple repair to bring your treasured piece back to life.
If you’re unsure, we always recommend getting a professional assessment before making a decision. A quick consultation could save you unnecessary expense — and help you preserve something truly special.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between repairing and replacing damaged jewellery isn’t always straightforward, but it doesn’t have to be stressful. Whether your piece needs a simple fix or a complete redesign, there’s almost always a way to honour its story and keep it shining for years to come.
At The Goldmarket, we’re passionate about helping you protect the pieces you love. Bring your jewellery to us for a no-obligation assessment — because every piece deserves a second chance to sparkle.
To see examples of our work, follow us on Instagram or Facebook or pop in and see us at 23 High Street, Weston-super-Mare, BS23 1HA.